Sunday, November 15, 2026

Jazz by Toni Morrison

Think how it is, if you can manage, just manage it. Nature freaks for you, then. Turns itself into shelter, byways. Pillows for two. Spreads the limbs of lilac bushes long enough to hide you. And the City, in its own way, gets down for you, cooperates, smoothing its sidewalks, correcting its curbstones, offering you melons and green apples on the corner. Racks of yellow head scarves; strings of Egyptian beads. Kansas fried chicken and something with raisins call attention to an open window where the aroma seems to lurk. And if that's not enough, doors to speakeasies stand ajar and in that cool dark place a clarinet coughs and clears its throat waiting for the woman to decide on the key. She makes up her mind and as you pass by informs your back that she is daddy's little angle child. The City is smart at this: smelling and good and looking and raunchy; sending secret messages disguised as public signs; this way, open here, danger to let colored only single men on sale women wanted private room stop dog on premises absolutely no money down fresh chicken free delivery fast.  And good at opening locks, dimming stairways. Covering your moans with its own.

Does anyone hate a chronological telling more than Toni Morrison? Jazz centers on an act of shocking violence, which lies at its core but is never really told, instead catapulting forward and back in time to capture the lead-up and aftermath: Joe Trace, a Harlem beauty products salesman, shoots and kills his teenage lover, Dorcas. Shortly afterward, Joe's wife Violet barges into the funeral and attempts to slash the dead Dorcas on the face. The why is actually fairly straightforward--Joe kills Dorcas because he's slighted by her attentions to a younger man, Violet tries to desecrate Dorcas out of jealousy and anger--but why exactly does Violet borrow a photograph of Dorcas from her grieving aunt and place it on the mantelpiece?

In some ways, Jazz is recognizable Morrison; in others, it seems like a wild departure. The best parts of the book by far are Morrison's evocation of 1920s-era Harlem--the New York of Gatsby and Passing--in a kind of free-wheeling, improvisational style that is meant to mimic, I think, the Jazz of the title. As a New Yorker, it's really satisfying to see the city through Morrison's eyes, which capture something about its vitality and vivacity through bursts of colorful prose like the one I quoted above. I know it's cliche to say "X place is its own character in this book," but it may be true about the city in Jazz, which pulses with life and strangeness. In part, Jazz is about the generations of Black Americans who moved north from the life of sharecroppers in the south; for Violet and Joe, who met in Virginia, the city is everything they've ever wanted. (So why isn't Joe satisfied? Is Dorcas a symbol of the disappointment of this new life, or its temptations?) I was really fascinated, too, by the first-person narrator, who doesn't seem to have an identity or a name, but still seems to be lurking somewhere among the alleyways to report on Joe and Violet.

It's the middle of the novel that feels most recognizably like Song of Solomon or Beloveed, when Morrison zooms back to the 19th century to examine the ancestors of Joe and Violet. The protagonists of this section are Golden Gray, a wealthy young man who discovers he has a black father, and "Wild," a "wild woman" that Gray discovers in the woods, pregnant and in distress. Morrison is trying to draw a comparison, clearly, between the seductive but independent "wild woman"--there's more than one in the Virginia woods, we're told--and a figure like Dorcas, who drives Joe to uncharacteristic recklessness. But here, unlike those other novels, I never felt that this section fit in the novel, nor did the histories illuminate the "modern" story in a way that worked. I was relieved, actually, when Morrison returned to the 1920s and the jazzy strangeness of New York City. Morrison's always a worthwhile read, but to me, this is one that, despite the high of its highs and the sheer joy of Morrison's New York, is ultimately deeply flawed.

No comments: