The Fifth Head of Cerberus by Gene Wolfe

When I was a boy my brother David and I had to go to bed early whether we were sleepy or not. In summer particularly, bedtime often came before sunset; and because our dormitory was in the east wing of the house, with a broad window facing the central courtyard and thus looking west, the hard, pinkish light sometimes streamed in for hours while we lay staring out at my father's crippled monkey perched on a flaking parapet, or telling stories, one bed to another, with soundless gestures.

Gene Wolf's The Fifth Head of Cerberus is a collection of three sort-of-linked novellas that take place on the twin planets of Sainte Anne and Sainte Croix. The first is narrated by an unnamed boy who discovers that he is the genetic clone of his father, destined--unlike his brother--to carry on his father's devious experiments. The second is a story purporting to be written by a minor character from the first, an anthropologist from Earth named Marsch, who comes to the planets to investigate the theories that Sainte Anne, when it was first colonized (by the French, lol) was actually populated by an aboriginal species of shapeshifters who either disappeared or learned to mimic their human colonizers so well that they actually took their place. Marsch's story is about two brothers who end up in different, hostile tribes, and the intervention of the mysterious "Shadow Children," who might be the remnants of a previous wave of human colonization. The third depicts Marsch in a jail cell, writing in his journal about the experience of exploring Sainte Anne with the help of a young peasant boy who claims, like his father, to actually be a shape-shifting "abo." Marsch has been jailed on suspicion of killing the boy, but as the novella goes on, we begin to suspect that the opposite is true: that the boy has killed Marsch, and taken his body and identity.

Even from that summary, you can see the themes that emerge: The Fifth Head of Cerberus is crowded with doubles, dopplegangers, and fakes. The first narrator's tutor, a suspiciously familiar robot named "Mr. Million," turns out to be his own genetic "great-grandfather," the first cloned copy, whose mind has been downloaded into the hard drive. The narrator tries to rebel against his father, killing him, but only ends up following his genetic destiny, repeating his father's work, and his father's before him. These doubles and doppelgangers are symbolized by the twin planets themselves, one which is believed to have had an aboriginal presence, and another which is believed to have been empty--but since the "abos" may have taken over their human colonizers, who can tell which is which?

But I was interested, too, in the book's image of colonization. In Marsch's story (which, of course, mustn't be taken as truth), the names of the pre-contact abos resemble those of Native Americans: "Cedar Branches Waving," etc. And the French colonial elements are pretty pointed. People on both planets are quick to make hard delineations between who is and isn't human: the lobotomized slaves in the market are "not people," and thus one can do whatever one wants with them, even though, as we learn, the slave markets are where the discarded clones of the narrators' father end up. The abos, if they exist, aren't "people" either, and the French descendants of Sainte Anne find easy justification in the prospect of their elimination. But there's something interesting and sneaky in the possibility that the abos have replaced the humans. It's easy to accept that the colonized are affected by the colonizers, but to what extent does the process happen in reverse? To what extent do Americans, for instance, deny the ways in which they are the inheritors of Indigenous culture rather than a European one? (We're not used to asking these questions, which are much more apparent in Mexico and Central America.)

The Fifth Head of Cerberus can be a frustrating read; nothing really is resolved or revealed. What revelations are to be found are unfolded slowly, and perhaps "revealed" only after they become obvious, but a larger truth about the existence of the abos, either in history or in the present, never really emerges. I felt the same way about The Book of the New Sun. Wolfe is a messy writer, full of digressions, and one who refuses to tie all his threads together in a way that a modern reader raised on HBO puzzle box shows will find satisfying. But that's what's most interesting and thrilling about his writing, too.